What is a Self Directed IRA Custodian?
Investing in alternative investments inside a retirement account (IRA, Roth IRA, SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA or 401k) is a new experience for most people. Anyone who has ever bought a traditional investment (a stock, bond, or mutual fund) has most likely already used a custodian for these investments. Although traditional custodians are frequently referred to as brokerage firms by investors, there is a difference between the two definitions.
- Brokerage firm – more accurately known as a broker-dealer, is a firm which is in the business of either buying or selling securities for its clients (broker) or buying or selling securities for itself (dealer). This means it makes its revenues from transacting securities for clients, or the trading securities for itself.
- Custodian – an institution which is responsible for records management and safekeeping of the assets within the client accounts. This type of firm typically generates revenues from its custody duties.
While the difference between a custodian and a brokerage firm is quite distinct, in many cases a firm may control both entities and seamlessly brand them as one entity. Many larger brokerage firms tend to have this setup. This can be confusing for many of the firm’s clients due to this obfuscation of terms, and lack of education generally available. If you are going to work with one of these types of firms, you should have a clear understanding of the services it can and will provide to you. It is preferable to work with a firm that has a clear specialization in one area so that it is clear what the risks, roles, and responsibilities are with the firm.
IRA Custodian vs. Self-Directed IRA Custodian?
The terms “IRA custodian” and “self-directed IRA custodian” technically mean the same thing. There is no definition of a “self-directed” IRA since all IRA accounts are self-directed by their definition. The difference in terms was most likely created as part of a marketing campaign to convince people that they should take control of their IRA by “self-directing” it. Regardless of the origins, the term “self-directed” helps to define what is quickly becoming a familiar term to describe an IRA which invests in alternative investments.
One of the requirements in the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) is that all IRA assets are held by a custodian. An IRA custodian can be split into two different specializations. The first type is the IRA custodian which specializes in publicly traded securities. This type is more commonly known due to the high percentage of the population which invests in stocks bonds and mutual funds. The second type is the IRA custodian which specializes in alternative investments, also known as a self-directed IRA custodian. This type is less commonly known due to the much smaller percentage of the population which invests in alternative investments with their IRA. Our firm uses both types of IRA custodians since we do not discriminate between asset types. This helps improve portfolio risk management by finding lower correlation assets.
Learn How to Choose a Self Directed IRA Custodian
Choosing a self-directed IRA custodian is an important task. The choice can have an impact on your investments, the amount of time spent managing them, and performance. It is important to research a number of self-directed IRA custodians. It is important to do this not only to make sure that the self-directed IRA custodian is the right fit for you but also to make sure it meets all the IRS requirements to be a legitimate IRA custodian.
While there are many factors to consider when choosing a self-directed IRA custodian, here are some of the more important ones.
- Specialization: While some IRA custodians specialize in traditional investments (stocks, bonds, and mutual funds), other IRA custodians (“self-directed”) specialize in alternative investments (real estate, private mortgages, tax liens, livestock, physical gold and silver, private company stock, or other non-traded security). There are even a few IRA custodians who will attempt to custody both types of investments. An IRA custodian who specializes in traditional investments, typically will not be the best one to also custody your alternative investments. The reverse holds true as well. When you work with a self-directed IRA custodian, you want to work with one whose specialty matches up with your needs. We have thoroughly reviewed almost all of the self-directed IRA custodians and while it is possible that one exists who is capable of handling both asset types well, we have not found one yet. It is important to know the strengths of your IRA custodian and to utilize them for those strengths.
- Fees: Every IRA custodian charges a fee for their services. In general, there are two models that are followed by self-directed IRA custodians, either a transaction fee model or an asset-based fee model. Make sure the custodian’s fee schedule aligns with your investment strategy. Your choice of self-directed IRA custodian is important because it will impact the total returns of your self-directed IRA. While some fees are negotiable, it typically only applies to larger accounts.
- Number of Transactions: Your investment strategy might be to buy one asset and hold it for 10 years or it might be to buy and sell assets 20-30 times in a week. Your IRA performance can be significantly impaired if the transaction expectations are not assessed properly and accounted for in the self-directed IRA custodian decision-making process. Automated services and a quick turnaround time at the self-directed IRA custodian are also important. If the IRA custodian is not prepared to properly handle multiple transactions in a timely manner, then it could affect your IRA investments. Some custodians offer services which can provide automation for repetitive transactions, or scheduled transaction activity. You should make sure your IRA custodian understands and is prepared to handle your transaction needs.
- Miscellaneous Fees: While this factor is important when using any IRA custodian, it is typically more relevant for self-directed IRA custodians. Many alternative investments require these services as part of the investment strategy, and almost all of the IRA custodians charge fees for these miscellaneous services. These services include activities such as: Fed Funds wires, notarizing documents, document storage, account setup fees, statement fees, transfer fees, account termination fees, and servicing fees such as check writing, processing documents, etc. Some custodians include these services in their custody fees, others itemize the fees and charge them separately. It is helpful to understand why the miscellaneous fees are being charged by the self-directed IRA custodian. The miscellaneous fees can be either pass-through or revenue generators for the self-directed IRA custodian. The pass-through fees are fees incurred by the custodian which they then pass along to the IRA account (for example fed funds wires, or postage). Revenue generator fees are a way for the IRA custodian to generate revenues for their services (for example notarizing documents, document storage fees, or account termination fees). Regardless of the reason for charging the fees, the bottom line is that all fees affect the portfolio’s net performance. Make sure the expected return on your investment takes into account all these miscellaneous fees.
- Service: This qualitative metric is one of the most overlooked areas in the due diligence process. This is a “wisdom through experience” process. Service is made up of important components such as: custodian depth of knowledge, timeliness of response, precision, consistency of a process, quick resolution to an issue, and willingness to adapt to an ever-changing environment. Self-directed IRA custodians require a high level of service due to the documentation requirements. For example, investing in a piece of real estate inside an IRA at a self-directed IRA custodian requires the custodian to process all documentation associated with the property (e.g. paying taxes, expenses, insurance, maintenance personnel, or other expenses). If the service team at the custodian is not very experienced in this type of transaction, or are slow in their response time, or are sloppy with their documentation processing, the investment could be negatively impacted. It is very important that this process is highly efficient.
How Innovative Advisory Group (IAG) can provide value to your investment portfolio.
IAG is a wealth management firm with an expertise of investing in alternative investments with self-directed IRAs and self-directed 401(k)s. We act as fiduciaries to our client, which requires that we use a high level of care with all our services.
When we manage alternative investments, we analyze each component of an investment transaction from start to finish. Our firm is focused on the process as much as the investment itself. One of the components of the process is the risk management analysis of a self-directed IRA custodian. Our firm conducts extensive due diligence on each self-directed IRA custodian we consider for our clients. This is part of our firm’s risk management process, to ensure that the highest quality IRA custodians are used, and the custodian is the right fit for the client’s investment strategy. We have written detailed reports on many of the top self-directed IRA custodians. If you are interested in learning more about our research, you can contact us.
If you are interested in joining our private email list, it is a great way to stay up to date on recent changes with self-directed IRAs, custodians, administrators, and other industry news.
We have compiled a complete list of self-directed IRA custodians and administrators for your use. If you want to access The Ultimate List of Self Directed IRA Custodians and Administrators, you can click here.
If you are an investment advisor who is considering which custodian to choose and you would like further guidance, we are available for consulting projects to help you determine this choice.
One Final Note: Passive custodians, generally are not allowed to provide advice, so investors should not rely on them exclusively to educate themselves on whether they are creating prohibited transactions, or whether the investment itself makes sense. Our firm provides investment advisory services such as investment due diligence, investment planning, and implementation, risk management, and more. We help guide investors through this complex process so they can meet their investment needs. Our services are complementary to most of the custodians you will ultimately choose. If you are interested in our advisory services, contact us to find out more.
Innovative Advisory Group Self Directed IRA Related Articles & Resources:
- What is a Self Directed Retirement Account?
- 9 Common Mistakes Investors Make Using a Self-Directed IRA
- The Quick Start Guide to Self-Directed IRAs
- 28 Questions to Ask Your Self Directed IRA Custodian
- The Ultimate List of Self Directed IRA Custodians & Administrators
- The Complete List of Advisors For Self Directed IRA Services
- The Ultimate Insider’s Guide to Self-Directed IRA Custodians and Administrators
- The Real Estate Investor’s Guide: Using a Self-Directed IRA to Buy Real Estate
- 5 Common Prohibited Transactions That Could Tax Your IRA
- The $100 Million Dollar Mitt Romney Self Directed IRA – How you can use these strategies to build one yourself
- Worried About Fraud with Your Self-Directed IRA? SEC Says, Ask a financial Advisor
About Innovative Advisory Group: Innovative Advisory Group, LLC (IAG), an independent Registered Investment Advisory Firm, is bringing innovation to the wealth management industry by combining both traditional and alternative investments. IAG is unique in that they have an extensive understanding of the regulatory and financial considerations involved with self-directed IRAs and other retirement accounts. IAG advises clients on traditional investments, such as stocks, bonds, and mutual funds, as well as advising clients on alternative investments—something most banks, brokerage firms and other IRA sponsors won’t permit you to do. IAG has a value-oriented approach to investing, which integrates specialized investment experience with extensive resources.
For more information, you can visit www.innovativewealth.com
About the author: Kirk Chisholm is a Wealth Manager and Principal at Innovative Advisory Group. His roles at IAG are co-chair of the Investment Committee and Head of the Traditional Investment Risk Management Group. His background and areas of focus are portfolio management and investment analysis in both the traditional and non-traditional investment markets. He received a BA degree in Economics from Trinity College in Hartford, CT.
Disclaimer: This article is intended solely for informational purposes only, and in no manner intended to solicit any product or service. The opinions in this article are exclusively of the author(s) and may or may not reflect all those who are employed, either directly or indirectly or affiliated with Innovative Advisory Group, LLC.